Residential

Park View Claim Review

London

Client

London Borough of Islington

Sector

Residential

Services

Dispute Resolution
Baily Garner provided advice on the merits of a contractor Extension of Time claim, and the possible strengths and weaknesses of the submission.

Baily Garner was appointed to provide expert advisory services in relation to a contractor’s Extension of Time (EoT) claim. Our role focused on assessing the merits of the submission and guiding the client on how best to respond, ensuring a fair and informed resolution process.

Our initial challenge stemmed from the limited documentation provided — we received only the contractor’s EoT submission and a series of referenced delay notices. This constrained our ability to fully assess the context and supporting evidence behind the claim. A key concern was the potential existence of contemporaneous correspondence or other relevant documentation that could materially impact the outcome, but which had not been shared with us.

To mitigate this risk, we requested a comprehensive list of supporting information. This allowed us to expand our review and provide advice with greater confidence and clarity.

We conducted a detailed review of the contractor’s submission, evaluating the strength of the arguments presented and identifying any weaknesses or inconsistencies. Our advice focused on the technical and contractual merits of the claim, based solely on the information available at the time.

Following our initial assessment, we held further meetings with the client to explore specific areas of the claim in more depth. We provided clear, actionable recommendations on how the client should respond, ensuring they were well-positioned to manage the situation effectively and in line with contractual obligations.

Project lead

Adam Pannell

Project Team Leader

Contact

To find out more about our work on this project, contact our Project Lead, Adam Pannell.

Be part of the journey

We believe the best outcomes are built on partnerships rooted in purpose, driven by insight, and fuelled by ambition. Whether you’re shaping places, transforming communities or redefining what’s possible, we’re here to help you make it happen.

Bring your next project to life

We believe the best outcomes are built on partnerships rooted in purpose, driven by insight, and fuelled by ambition. Whether you're shaping places, transforming communities or redefining what’s possible, we’re here to help you make it happen.

Contact us

Join the team and do something amazing

Our multidisciplinary teams work with clarity and purpose to turn your vision into value. By combining insight, innovation, and technical excellence, we shape places that make a real difference.

Find out more
Residential

Party Representative in an Adjudication

Sussex, Surrey and Kent

Client

Trinity Homes

Sector

Residential

Services

Dispute Resolution

Project Value

£5,593,834
Baily Garner provided dispute resolution services across multiple high-value construction projects, supporting Trinity in navigating complex contractual disagreements.

Baily Garner represented Trinity Homes in a contractual dispute concerning the release of retention monies. The Employer had withheld payment due to alleged issues, prompting our client to seek advice on the most effective route to resolution. With limited experience in alternative dispute resolution, Trinity Homes relied on our expertise to guide them through the adjudication process — ultimately securing a successful outcome.

One of the primary challenges was the tight timeframe associated with adjudication. Once the Referral Notice was issued, a decision was required within 28 days unless an extension was agreed. The Employer delayed their Response, compressing the time available for us to prepare a Reply. An extension was eventually granted by the Adjudicator due to the volume of information submitted, but we still had only a few days to respond comprehensively.

Another challenge was information gathering. Our client, the contractor, had limited documentation readily accessible. To ensure we had all relevant material for the Referral Notice, we visited the client’s offices and worked collaboratively to identify and extract key project information from their records.

We advised Trinity Homes on the available dispute resolution options, ultimately recommending adjudication as the most efficient path forward. Once agreed, we led the process — drafting the Notice of Adjudication and Referral Notice, and liaising directly with the appointed Adjudicator.

Upon receiving the Employer’s Response, we quickly developed a detailed Reply, addressing all points raised. Our strategic approach and thorough preparation led to a successful adjudication outcome on all issues, securing the withheld retention payment for our client and bringing the dispute to a positive resolution.

Project lead

Adam Pannell

Project Team Leader

Contact

To find out more about our work on this project, contact our Project Lead, Adam Pannell.

Be part of the journey

We believe the best outcomes are built on partnerships rooted in purpose, driven by insight, and fuelled by ambition. Whether you’re shaping places, transforming communities or redefining what’s possible, we’re here to help you make it happen.

Bring your next project to life

We believe the best outcomes are built on partnerships rooted in purpose, driven by insight, and fuelled by ambition. Whether you're shaping places, transforming communities or redefining what’s possible, we’re here to help you make it happen.

Contact us

Join the team and do something amazing

Our multidisciplinary teams work with clarity and purpose to turn your vision into value. By combining insight, innovation, and technical excellence, we shape places that make a real difference.

Find out more
Safety hat

Sign up to
our newsletter

Sign up to
our newsletter

Get the latest insights

Enter your email address to join our newsletter.